Niantic’s pizza scene is a blend of traditional recipes and innovative creations that represent this Connecticut coastal town. From family-owned establishments that have been serving the community for decades to newer spots bringing fresh ideas to the table, Niantic offers pizza lovers an impressive variety of options. What makes these top five pizzerias stand out is their commitment to quality—using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients whenever possible, perfecting distinctive styles from classic New Haven-inspired thin crust to thick, hearty Sicilian squares, and creating warm, inviting atmospheres that welcome both locals and visitors alike.
Each of these must-try pizza destinations brings something special to Niantic’s culinary landscape. Some pride themselves on traditional wood-fired ovens that create that perfect char on their crusts, while others focus on creative topping combinations that you won’t find anywhere else. If you’re looking for a casual family dinner, a quick lunch by the shore, or a relaxed evening with friends over excellent food, these five establishments cover all the bases. What’s more, they reflect the community spirit of Niantic, with many owners and staff knowing their regular customers by name and pizza preferences—creating that small-town charm that makes dining here such a pleasure.
Castello Of Niantic
If you want to experience true Italian flavors, Castello Of Niantic is the place to be. Nestled in the heart of town, this cozy spot offers a perfect balance between a casual family-friendly environment and fine Italian dining. Castello is known for its rich, traditional pies made with love and precision. From classic Margherita to their signature Prosciutto & Arugula pizza, every bite feels like a trip to Italy. What makes Castello special is their commitment to using fresh ingredients, which brings the authentic flavors to life.
Why locals love it: Castello Of Niantic doesn’t just serve pizza; it provides an experience. Locals rave about the exceptional service and warm atmosphere that makes you feel like part of the family. It’s an absolute staple for anyone looking to enjoy quality pizza by the sea.
Vincitori Apizza
When it comes to local favorites, Vincitori Apizza holds a special place in the hearts (and stomachs) of Niantic residents. Rooted in the rich Italian-American pizza tradition, Vincitori Apizza offers a wide variety of pies that celebrate old-world techniques with a fresh, modern twist. Their thin-crust pizzas, fired to perfection in brick ovens, have the perfect balance of crispy crust and gooey cheese. Whether you’re indulging in their pepperoni-loaded classic or trying their garlic and clam white pizza, Vincitori consistently impresses.
Why locals love it: The wood-fired oven adds a smokiness to the crust that’s hard to replicate. Locals can’t get enough of the crispy, golden edges, and the inventive combinations that keep them coming back for more.
Family Pizza Restaurant
Family Pizza Restaurant is exactly what it sounds like: a place where families gather to enjoy good food and create lasting memories. A long-time favorite in Niantic, this spot serves up pizzas that are as warm and comforting as the atmosphere itself. You’ll find no-frills, hearty pizzas topped with everything from classic pepperoni to loaded veggie delights. Perfect for casual dinners, birthdays, or just a night out with friends, Family Pizza is a reminder that sometimes simple is best.
Why locals love it: The laid-back, friendly atmosphere, along with consistently delicious food, makes this place a go-to for Niantic families. It’s the kind of place where the staff knows your name, and your favorite pizza order is always served just the way you like it.
Black Point Pizza
Tucked away near the scenic Black Point Beach, Black Point Pizza is a lesser-known treasure that Niantic locals love to keep secret. Known for its generous toppings, flavorful crust, and creative specialty pies, this pizzeria stands out not just for its food but also for its cozy, beachy vibe. The restaurant offers a unique pizza experience with seafood-inspired toppings that give a nod to Niantic’s coastal location. Their Clams Casino pizza is a must-try!
Why locals love it: The combination of fresh, coastal ingredients with the casual ambiance of a beachside spot makes Black Point Pizza feel like a hidden local treasure. It’s a perfect place to refuel after a day at the beach.
Village Pizza and Grille Restaurant
Village Pizza and Grille Restaurant is a favorite among those who want their pizza fast, hot, and satisfying. They serve up everything from classic cheese and pepperoni to inventive gourmet pizzas. With a wide range of toppings and crust options, Village Pizza makes sure that every bite is bursting with flavor. The versatility of their menu also extends to other comfort foods like calzones, grinders, and pasta dishes, so there’s always something for everyone.
Why locals love it: Village Pizza offers a sense of community, and with a menu that’s packed with variety, there’s something for every craving. The casual, no-fuss setting combined with delicious food makes this spot a mainstay for both locals and visitors.
Why Niantic’s Pizza Scene Will Make You Fall in Love
Pizza is a reflection of the community in the USA—warm, inviting, and deeply satisfying—and nowhere is that truer than in Niantic. The charm of Niantic isn’t just in the beautiful coastal views or historic charm; it’s in the local eateries that bring people together. These five pizza spots embody that sense of community and hospitality, offering more than just great food—they offer a taste of what makes Niantic special.
Thinking about moving to Niantic? Beyond the incredible food scene, Niantic offers the perfect balance of small-town charm, coastal beauty, and a tight-knit community that’s hard to find anywhere else. From strolls along the Niantic Bay Boardwalk to quaint shops and friendly faces, this is a town where everyone feels welcome—and well-fed.
Whether you’re planning a visit or considering making Niantic your home, one thing’s for sure: the pizza here is just one of many reasons you’ll fall in love with this coastal Connecticut town.
